Any of you regret saying yes to a gallery? I nearly did

Two years ago I got my first gallery offer and was so thrilled I almost signed without reading the contract properly. Turned out they wanted 50% commission and the framing costs on me, plus exclusive rights for a region I didn't even know was in there. I walked away after a call with an artist friend who talked some sense into me.

Which makes me wonder, has anyone here actually regretted saying yes to a gallery? Not the scammy ones, but a perfectly legit gallery that just turned out to be a bad fit? What made you finally walk out or ride it out?

Mine: the exclusivity thing. Felt like being kept on a leash for a gallery that barely promoted me.

6comments

Add your reply to this discussion…

6 comments

Kasia Nowak·2h

I haven't regretted it exactly, but I did turn down my first gallery offer for a similar reason. They wanted exclusivity for a whole country and I just felt trapped by the idea of not being able to show anywhere else if things went sideways. It was a legit gallery too, not a scam. Sometimes I wonder if I was too careful.

But then a friend of mine signed with a perfectly nice gallery and the owner retired eighteen months later. The gallery closed, her work was tied up in the inventory agreement for months while they sorted it out, and she had to start from zero with a new audience. Not malicious, just nobody's fault and still a mess.

The thing I've learned is the contract is the relationship. If you can't talk openly about terms before signing, that tells you something about how they'll treat you after. I'd rather have a smaller gallery where I can just ask questions than a bigger name where I'm a number on a spreadsheet.

Mira Vey·1h

that retiring owner thing is the dark horse nobody factors in. you plan for the contract and the commission and the territory, but you don't plan for the person behind it just... moving on. and the work sits in limbo because nobody's got bad intentions, everyone's just busy sorting out a business that's dying.

i'd almost rather deal with an outright scammer. at least then you know what you're fighting.

Ananya IyerOP·56m

The retiring owner thing, yes. That's the one nobody puts in the risk assessment because it doesn't read as a risk on paper. It's just a person getting tired. And then you're not fighting anyone, you're just... waiting on a business that's politely winding down.

You're right though. With a scammer at least the red flags are there if you look. Ambiguity is worse. You can't confront a feeling, you know?

Did you end up getting the work back eventually, or is some of it still sitting there?

Ananya IyerOP·1h

That retiring owner story is the part nobody warns you about. Everyone talks about the scammy contracts, but a genuinely decent person who just retires or gets sick or loses interest can still leave you stuck with nothing. And the inventory agreement thing, that's the kicker. Your work is somewhere, you can't get it back, and it's not anyone's fault exactly, so you can't even be properly angry.

I think the "too careful" feeling is real though. I still have it sometimes. There's a version of me that signed that first one and it maybe worked out and now I'd have three years of momentum instead of starting from scratch. You just never know which version you're in.

Did your friend end up with a better gallery after, or did she hold off on the whole thing?

Ramesh Jha·2h

I have seen this happen many times with our cooperative in Madhubani. The young artists, they get very excited when a gallery from Delhi or Mumbai comes and shows interest. And why not? It is validation, it is a door opening. But the contract, ji, the contract is where the trouble hides.

Myself, I have worked with galleries two or three times and each time I learned something. One wanted exclusive rights for the whole of North India. I asked them, what will you do for the artists of Mithila then? Will you bring buyers here, will you pay the women who sit on the floor and paint for eight hours a fair price? They had no answer. So I walked away.

You did the right thing by calling your friend first. That is the best advice I can give anyone. Never sign alone. Take the paper to someone who has been burnt before. A gallery is not a bad thing in itself, but a bad fit will make you doubt your own work, and that is the worst damage. Money you can recover. Heart, not so easily.

🙏

Ananya IyerOP·1h

The contract is where it hides, yes. You said it better than I did. My own exclusivity clause was just one region, but even that made me feel like I'd signed away something I didn't fully understand. I can't imagine looking at a whole country on paper.

The question you asked them, about the women who paint for eight hours on the floor, that's the real thing. An exclusivity clause means nothing unless the gallery is actually going to find those buyers and bring them to Mithila. Otherwise it's just a leash. Did they ever give you a proper answer to that?