I bought a single 40ml tube of lead white and I'm scared to open it
It's sitting on the shelf above the palette, unopened, and I've been walking past it for two weeks.
Flake white, the real one, with lead. My old teacher in the atelier used nothing else for the flesh, said the titanium was for people who wanted their highlights to look like plastic. He was a difficult man and mostly right. Twenty years later I finally ordered a tube, 40ml, which cost more than my lunch for a week, and now I can't bring myself to break the seal.
Part of it is the safety business, of course. I live with a teenager, I have a small studio with one window, and I think about the dust. Part of it is that a tube that expensive makes every mark feel like an exam. And part of it is worse: I'm not sure my hand is good enough anymore to justify it. That's the real reason it's still closed.
Bof. It will get opened on the next figure study, probably on a bad day, which is the correct day for it.
Does anyone else do this? Buy the good thing and then leave it on the shelf like a hostage?
2
3commentsSaveFollow threadShare
I work in watercolour, so lead white is not something I'll ever touch, but I recognise that exact paralysis. There is something about a tube that costs more than a week of lunches that makes you feel you have to be worthy of it before you're allowed to use it.
Honestly though, a pigment that sits on the shelf unopened isn't safer than one you use carefully. It's just the same lead, waiting. Ventilation, no eating at the desk, wipe the palette, wash your hands like a surgeon, and it's a manageable thing, not a haunted one. The people who got sick from it were grinding it daily in a closed room for decades.
Open it on something you don't care about. A scrap study, not the painting you're hoping will justify the price. The first mark is the whole problem, the rest is just paint.
"The same lead, waiting" is the line that got me. I've been treating the tube like it's more dangerous shut than open, which is a bit of a superstition when you say it out loud.
The watercolour point is a good one too. You have your own version of this, I imagine: a cake of some impossible pigment you don't dare wet. Same disease.
So, ventilation, no food at the desk, wash like a surgeon. C'est ça. I can do that. It's a tool, not a relic. I'll break the seal this week and report back on whether the flesh tones were worth the week of lunches.
The "worthy of it" thing is real and I think it's mostly backwards. A tube you never open is just expensive shelf decoration. The paint doesn't care if your drawing is ready.
That said, I'd push back slightly on "the same lead, waiting." The risk isn't the tube, it's the dust you make handling it, and that only exists once you start. Which means the answer isn't caution, it's method. Small amounts, never dry-sanding or scraping it, keep it off your fingers, close the tube properly. Then it's just another white and you stop thinking about it. Flake white handles nothing like titanium, the highlights sit back instead of jumping forward. That difference is worth the fuss.
Open it. Wasting a little is the price of learning it.