I keep reaching for the eraser on the one part that's actually working
so there's this piece on my wall, a big one, roughly 4ft x 3ft, built up over about five weeks. charcoal and acrylic wash on a torn-up photo of my grandmother's kitchen. and the section I keep standing in front of is the bottom left corner, where the paper tore badly and I patched it with a piece from an old letter instead of redoing it.
it's the only part of the whole thing I trust. it looks like a scar over a scar.
and yet every single time I walk past, my hand goes for the sandpaper. because it's messy, because it's not what I planned, because some part of me still thinks the point is to make the neat version.
I know this about myself by now and I still do it. the tidy instinct is a hard habit to kill when you were raised to believe mess isn't worth keeping.
I left it alone last night. went to bed. haven't touched it today either. small victories.
mostly I'm wondering how you all tell the difference between "this is the good accident, protect it" and "this is actually just wrong and I'm romanticizing it because I'm scared to redo the work." because I genuinely can't always tell.
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
The part you trust is the part that happened to you rather than the part you decided. That's not a coincidence and it's not sentimentality either. The patch is the only place on that wall where the material pushed back, and your hand knows it before your head does.
The sandpaper impulse is real though, and I wouldn't pretend it's just nerves. Five weeks of planning builds a picture of the finished thing in your head, and the corner doesn't match that picture. But the picture is the least interesting thing you've made here. Sand it and you'll get a tidy corner and lose the only scar in the piece. Leave it and you'll have to accept that the best moment was an accident you didn't author. That's the actual choice, and it's uncomfortable for a reason.
One practical thing: put the sandpaper in another room for a week. Not a noble gesture, just remove the option. If in seven days you still want it gone, you'll know it's judgment and not reflex.
The letter paper didn't "let" you win, it made you choose. That's a different muscle than the one you've been using for five weeks, and it's the one that actually makes the thing yours. I work in mosaic and the best passages in anything I finish are always the ones where a piece broke wrong and I had to build around it. Sandpaper is just you trying to un-choose it. Leave the corner alone and go work on the other side of the piece for a week, see if the impulse fades when you're not staring at it.
"sandpaper is just you trying to un-choose it" ok that one landed. and you're right that it's a different muscle, five weeks of deciding vs one afternoon of getting outvoted by a letter.
the mosaic thing makes sense to me. you can't argue with a piece that broke, it's already done arguing. can I ask though, when you build around a break, do you ever get it to where you stop seeing the break first? because that's the part I'm afraid of. right now the patch is the first thing I look at and I don't know if that's because it's good or just because it's loud.
"the material pushed back" is the phrase I'm going to be chewing on all week. that's exactly it, the letter paper didn't want to sit flat and I let it win because I had no choice.
but here's the thing that's making me nervous: I don't know if I can tell the difference anymore between a scar and a mistake I've decided to love. the corner is good, I know it's good. the rest of the piece though. the picture I built up in my head over five weeks, is that dead? because if it is, sanding one corner isn't going to fix it, it's just the first thing my hand found.