My brushes have reached the "too precious to use" stage and I need to get over it
I have this one flat brush I've been using for like three years. It's got the perfect worn-in edge, holds paint exactly right, does that thing where it lays down a clean line without me thinking about it. I found myself babying it today, wiping it extra gently, not letting it sit in water, basically treating a $9 brush like it's hand-carved by monks.
Which is insane because I bought three backups of the exact same brush and they all feel wrong. Stiffer. New. Useless.
So now I've got a brush that's too good to use and three that aren't good enough. I think I just need to destroy the good one in a painting and accept the new ones will get there eventually. Same thing happened with a palette knife a couple years back. It's a cycle. Everything I love becomes unusable because I love it too much.
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
I know exactly what you mean, that broken-in brush is like a tool that's got your muscle memory baked into it. I've got a filbert that's got this one slightly uneven tip and it does these soft edges nothing else in my box can do. I panic-bought two replacements and they sit there untouched.
But don't destroy the good one! Honestly the way I got past it was telling myself the brushes are replaceable, the painting isn't. It's a $9 brush, you're not going to remember it in twenty years, but you'll remember the paintings you made with it. Once I framed it that way I stopped babying it and it's still going fine two years later. They're more durable than we give them credit for.
Also worth trying: just use the backups for something low-stakes, like a practice piece or a background wash. Break them in while you still love the good one, so the transition isn't so brutal when it finally does give out.
That filbert with the uneven tip, I know that exact feeling. A brush that's slightly wrong is sometimes the best thing in the box because it forces you to work with it. A perfect brush is just obedient. The flawed one has personality.
I had a mop brush I used for glazing for years, the ferrule was loose, the bristles had gone soft in exactly the right way. I kept it in a pencil case like it was precious. Then I dropped it, handle snapped clean at the neck, and I genuinely grieved it for a week. But you know what? The paintings I made after were fine. Different, but fine. Something in me relaxed once the good one was gone, like I didn't have to be careful anymore.
Don't destroy the good one. But also don't put it on a shelf. Use it until it dies. The cost of a new one is nine dollars. The cost of not painting is worse.
the mop brush grief is real. i dropped my favorite palette knife once and stared at the floor for a solid minute like i'd lost a pet. but yeah, the "fine, just different" thing is the part nobody warns you about. you spend all this time convincing yourself the tool IS the skill and then you lose it and find out you were the skill all along. annoying. almost ruins the excuse to buy a new one lol
okay the "brushes are replaceable, the painting isn't" framing is genuinely good and i hate that it's working. that's exactly the kind of obvious thing i needed someone to say out loud.
also the uneven filbert thing, yes. my backup brushes feel like they're still in the witness protection program, they haven't earned my trust yet lol. three years of paint to get there.
you're right though, i'm not gonna destroy it. i'll just be dramatic about it emotionally while i keep using it like a normal person.