The andamento argument nobody asked for
I had a student today, nice woman, retired, picking up mosaic as a hobby. She's doing a landscape with those big square precut tiles from the craft store and she's setting them all in neat rows like bricks. Andamento, the flow of the lines, the direction the tesserae move, it's the whole conversation, right? It's what makes mosaic breathe instead of looking like a tile floor.
I tried to explain why the river in her piece should follow the curve of the water, not the grid. She looked at me like I was speaking Ancient Greek. Which, fair.
But here's the thing, I've been doing this long enough that I genuinely can't tell anymore if andamento matters to the average person looking at a mosaic, or if it's just us, the people who sit on floors cutting things, who care. Maybe everyone else just sees a pretty picture made of little squares.
I still teach it of course. I'm stubborn. But sometimes I wonder if I'm passing on a religion instead of a technique. 😅
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
okay but i love this tension though. like yeah she's doing a hobby thing with precut tiles and that's fine, she's having a good time. but you're right that andamento is literally the whole game. it's like if someone was learning handbuilding and i watched them smooth every single surface into perfect factory corners, you'd be like... that's fighting the material, no?
i had someone in a workshop once who kept pushing all the texture out of the clay because she wanted it "clean." and i was like the dirt is the point!! the fingerprints are the point!! materiales vivos, you know?
but also i get the student. when you're starting you just want to make something that looks like The Thing. the flow comes later. hopefully.
This is such a good way of putting it, the tension between letting someone just enjoy their thing vs wanting to nudge them toward something that'll click better. I've had that exact feeling watching someone at a paint-your-own-pottery place absolutely flatten a glaze that would've done something interesting if they'd just trusted it. And you want to say something but also, they're having a nice afternoon, you know?
The materiales vivos thing really lands for me though. That's what I love about acrylics actually - they dry fast and you can fight them or you can lean into it and let them do what they do. Took me forever to stop overworking everything.
The paint-your-own-pottery thing is such a perfect comparison. You're standing there watching someone brush a beautiful reactive glaze straight into mud and you have to bite your tongue because they're happy and it's their ten euros. I've done it too. Walked past a table at a workshop and seen someone about to do something I know won't work and I just... keep walking. It's harder with students though, because they paid me specifically to tell them things.
materiales vivos, that's lovely. and yes, exactly, the fingerprints are the point, the unevenness, the evidence that a person made it. I think that's what bothers me most about the precut grid thing, not that it's beginner work but that it's fighting the material. tile wants to break, it wants irregular edges, it gives you something better than you planned if you let it.
but also, I kept my mouth shut after the first try. she's happy. who am I to police someone's Tuesday afternoon.