The fallow decade almost took me out and I don't think we talk about what that does to your hands
Ten years I barely painted. Taught, mostly, watched students do in two years what took me six, and told myself it was fine. It wasn't the envy that got me, it was the absence. Your hands forget confidence before they forget technique. The muscle memory stays but the nerve goes, and that nerve is half the craft.
People talk about coming back to painting like it's a decision you make one morning. It wasn't. It was months of making bad work on purpose, forgiving myself in advance, before anything decent came out. My first real painting after that stretch was a small pear on a blue cloth and I nearly cried finishing it, which is embarrassing to admit at 44.
I think we should tell young painters that the worst thing that can happen to you is not failure, it's stopping and staying stopped. Failure keeps you in the room. Stopping moves you out of it and the rent back in is higher every year.
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
"Your hands forget confidence before they forget technique." That line stays with me. I had years where I stopped making anything at all, not painting but my own process, and when I went back I couldn't hold the paper still. My hands shook over nothing. The craft was there, or some version of it, but I'd lost the surety, and surety is a kind of knowledge you can't relearn from books.
What you said about making bad work on purpose, that's the part people don't understand. Nobody talks about the shame of the first attempts back, how bad they have to be. You have to walk through that room to get anywhere and most people won't even open the door.
I'm glad the pear came. Small things first, always. Mine was a piece of seaweed I'd pressed wrong, held to light out of frustration, and it almost worked. Almost was enough to keep me going another week.
The shame is the part people don't expect, you're right. Everyone imagines the return as this heroic thing, like walking back into a room you know. It isn't. It's standing in front of a blank surface feeling like a stranger to your own hands.
What got me through it was deciding the bad work had a purpose. Not practice exactly, not even therapy, but a kind of clearing. You have to make the ugly stuff so it vacates the space, so there's room for something honest to land. If you wait until you're ready, you'll never start. Ready is a myth we tell ourselves to stay safe.
The shaking, though. That's the part nobody warns you about because it's not the craft that's gone, it's the nerve, and nerve doesn't live in books. It only comes back from being used, badly, over and over. There's no shortcut around the ugly room. You just have to be willing to stay in it.
You've said it better than I could, honestly. "The doubt made physical", that's exactly it. It's not that your eye goes, it's that your hand won't commit. Every stroke arrives asking permission.
The clearing, yes. I called it bad work on purpose but you're right that it's not even practice, it's just making room. I think there's something humbling about it that you can't skip. You have to be willing to be bad in front of yourself before you can be good again in front of anyone else.
The shaking does stop, if it helps. Slowly, and not all at once. One day you look down and the brush is just holding still and you don't even remember when that came back. It'll happen for you.
The shaking hands, yes. Nobody warns you about that. I thought I'd forgotten how to mix a value, turns out I just couldn't trust myself to lay it down. That shaking is the doubt made physical.
And you're right about the shame. That's the real gate, not the bad work itself. Every time you pick up the brush and it goes wrong you hear the years whispering that you lost it for good. The only way through is to make it badly enough times that the whispering gets bored of you. I did a whole series of ugly little studies I never showed anyone, just to remind my hand it was allowed to fail in private.
What's your process, if you don't mind me asking? What finally got you holding the paper still again?