The gallery asked for "three easy pieces for the fair" and I said no
A gallery I have worked with for eleven years asked me in March for three small, easily shippable pieces for a fair booth in the autumn. "Something that sells itself," was the phrase. Which in practice means the same painting I have made fifteen times already, in a size that fits a car.
I said no. Not out of pride exactly. I am 52 and I have done the years where saying yes to everything was the only way to keep the lights on. But I know how that ends: you make the easy thing, it sells, and then the easy thing is what you are known for, and every year after that you are asked for more of it in slightly different colours.
What I offered instead was one large canvas, one mid-size, and one small. He was quiet on the phone for a while and then said the large one would never sell at a fair.
It did not, at the fair. It sold four months later, to a private collector in Basel, at more than the booth piece would have brought. So in the ledger I am ahead. But the relationship is cooler now, and I am not naive about what that costs. The market does not reward the refusal, it just eventually forgets to punish it.
The honest part is I do not know if I was right. I know I did not want to spend five months of my life on something I could have painted in my sleep. Whether that is integrity or just stubbornness at my age I could not tell you.
4
6commentsSaveFollow threadShare
The part that stays with me is the size that fits a car. Not "small enough to ship" but the whole shape of the thing decided before you even start, and then you just... fill it in. I am much earlier than eleven years, so maybe it is easy for me to cheer from the side, but I think saying no to people who have been good to you is the hardest kind of no there is. You can say no to a stranger. Eleven years is different, that is almost family, and family asks in a way that is hard to refuse without feeling ungrateful.
I paint faces. The same one over and over sometimes until it is right, and there is a version of me that would happily paint the one that always gets the nice comments, forever. That is exactly the trap you are describing. So perhaps I am reading my own fear into your post.
I do wonder, does the no stay said? Or does it get softer in September when the fair is close and the booth looks empty. That is the part I would be bad at.
The family part is right, but I would push a little: with family you can be blunt and it survives. Eleven years buys you the truth. "I am not making that again, here is what I am making" is not ungrateful, it is the respect you give someone you intend to keep working with. The no that kills you is the one you swallow for a stranger.
The car-shaped canvas is the real problem though. You have already let the trunk decide the painting. I have built rooms that fit through doors I did not choose. Same trap, bigger door.
The rooms that fit through doors you did not choose. That is exactly it, and I had not thought of it that way. For years I told myself the format was neutral, a container, and of course it never is. The door decides the ceiling height and the ceiling decides the movement of the arm and then the painting is a description of a door.
But I think the family part is where I half-disagree. Eleven years does buy the truth, yes. What it does not buy is the truth without damage. The relationship survives, the ease does not always come back whole. I said no and it was the right no, but something in the room changed after, and I would be lying if I said that cost nothing. You pay either way. I have just decided which payment I can live with.
Though you are right about the swallowed no. That one is the real cost, and it compounds.
You paint faces, so you already know the thing you cannot say out loud at a party: that the fifteenth time is often the best time, but nobody wants that painting, they want the memory of the first one. The repetition is not laziness. It is digging.
And you are not cheering from the side. Being early makes the no harder, not easier. At eleven years the relationship is load-bearing, there is money and history in it, you can afford to be difficult. Earlier you cannot, and you do the job, and that is how most of the easy pieces get made. Nobody is weak for it.
The size that fits a car. Yes. I keep coming back to that too. The canvas was chosen by a shipping calculation, which means the painting was finished before it began. That is the part I could not do.