the last photo of my brother's kitchen is in the piece and I think it's doing all the work for me
working on a piece right now, about 30 x 40, acrylic wash over a torn paper ground, and there's a found photograph in it. my brother's kitchen. bad exposure, his hand at the edge of the frame, you can see a dish towel on the counter.
the problem: the photo is the best thing in it. people look at the piece and go quiet and I know they're not looking at my paint, they're looking at him. which fine, that's the point, but it also means I could put a brick next to that photo and get the same reaction. charcoal underneath it feels like decoration now.
I've done this before and I don't think I've ever solved it. the photo does the emotional labor and the rest of the surface just hangs around it. I keep telling myself to bury the photo deeper, varnish it, tear it, so you have to work to find it, but every time I try it reads as precious instead of honest.
not really asking if I should take it out, I know I shouldn't. asking how you get the rest of the surface to earn its place instead of standing next to the thing that actually matters. or is that just what this kind of work is and I should stop fighting it
2
2commentsSaveFollow threadShare
honestly the "i could put a brick next to that photo" line is the whole thing. that's not a problem with your paint, that's just what a found photo does, it's got a person in it and paint doesn't compete with a person on pure emotional payload. it never will.
the question is whether you want the paint to compete or to frame. i stopped trying to beat the photo years ago and started treating the paint as the room the photo sits in. bad exposure and the dish towel are doing more than any clean shot would, the mess is the feeling.
but if it keeps eating the piece every time, maybe the move is making the paint argue with the photo instead of decorate it. paint the kitchen wrong. the wrong color, the wrong light, the counter on the wrong side. give people a reason to look at your hand and not just his.
"the room the photo sits in" is going to sit with me, that's a better frame than anything I had.
the dish towel thing, yeah. I almost cropped it out early on, thought it was noise. kept it because it was the last thing in his kitchen that was actually his and not just a wall. so it stays.
what you said about not competing, I think I've been fighting that without admitting it. I keep adding charcoal like I'm trying to earn the photo, like the piece has to justify why there's paint on it at all. maybe it doesn't.
the smaller version is interesting. do you mean physically smaller or just less of it around the photo? because I did try a test where I pulled the wash way back and it read almost like an envelope, which was worse in a different way.