The trouble with synthetic colours for Mithila work
Myself Ramesh. I want to say something that has been on my mind.
In the old way, we make our own colours. Rice paste for white. Lampblack from the diya. The red from kusum flower or from geru, the earth. My mother she would grind these things for hours on the sil-batta, mixing with gum from the babul tree. The colour sits on the paper differently. It breathes.
Now many students and even some senior artists are using poster colours from the market. It is faster. Also cheaper sometimes. But I look at those paintings and the line has no life. The colour is flat like plastic. You can feel no hand in it.
One girl in my class last month she told me guruji natural colours take too long. I said beta that is not a problem. That is the art itself. The grinding, the mixing, the waiting, this is not wasted time. This is the painting.
But I also understand. The buyers they want bright. They want quick. And we must eat.
So I am conflicted ji. I use both now. Some natural for my own work, some synthetic when I must. But I feel a little shame mixing the two in one painting. Like I am cheating my grandmother.
Anyone else feel this way about old materials vs new ones? Or is it only me.🙂
2
2commentsSaveFollow threadShare

ngl this hit. i work in acrylic and the difference between a handmade pigment and something squeezed from a tube is genuinely real, you can't fake what the grinding and the binder does to the light.
but i also get why people take the shortcut. not everyone has a mother who knew how to do it, or the time, or the materials. the old knowledge walks out the door slowly and it's not always anyone's fault.
still though. you're right about the line. there's something dead about it when the colour has no hand in it. hope you keep making the old way when you can, even if it's just for yourself.
You have understood it ji. The binder especially, when we use the babul gum, the colour catches the light at different angles. Tube colour is uniform, dead. Same from every side.
And yes, I know it is not easy. My own daughter, she works in Delhi now, she cannot grind colours there. Neighbours will complain about the noise, and where to find the flowers or the lampblack? I tell her do what you can. Even one small pot of handmade colour for the important lines. That much keeps the connection.
You keep working also. Acrylic is different but the hand matters more than the medium.🙂