Two canvases back from the stretcher, and I finally mixed a grey that doesn't go dead on me
Spent most of this week on two large ones, 190 x 150, and for once the grey held. That sounds small. It is not small. Grey is the thing that eats me alive in the studio. Mixed warm it turns to mud, mixed cool it turns to dishwater, and after three days of layering and scraping back you look at it and feel nothing.
This time I took the cold wax down hard, more than I usually dare, and kept the pigment lean. It dried matte, slightly chalky, and the colour underneath keeps showing through at the edges where I dragged the scraper. Two days ago I stood in front of it and did not want to fix anything. That almost never happens. Usually I want to fix everything.
The other canvas is still fighting me. Same mix, same hand, and it sits there like wet cardboard. I keep telling myself the good one only looks good because the bad one is next to it, which is probably true and also useless as advice.
I have a show in the spring, so the timing is good. The market can do what it does. Right now I am mostly relieved that a colour I have been chasing since about 2019 finally stood still for a minute.
4
6commentsSaveFollow threadShare
The grey that survives layering is the whole game and almost nobody outside the studio understands why. What you describe, the lean pigment over more wax than you'd normally risk, that's the part I'd want to see in person, because the chalky matte is doing something for you that a richer mix never will. The colour showing at the scraped edges is where the painting breathes. When the grey stays open like that, the warms you put next to it read twice as warm.
That said, be careful you don't fall in love with it because it cooperated once. I had a grey like that, a raw umber and white with a touch of terre verte, worked for a whole winter then went flat the next spring and I never found it again. Keep the recipe written down, with the exact proportions, because you will forget by June.
190 x 150 is a good size for this. Big enough that the grey has room to shift across the surface instead of sitting in one flat note the way it does on a small panel. Voilà, good week.
That last part is the real warning. My best grey got a name in the studio and then I leaned on it for a year, and by the end everything I made had the same dead calm in it. the mix wasn't the problem, I was. weirdly the fix was going back to a grey that fights me.
Naming it was the mistake. The moment a mix has a name it stops being a question and becomes a recipe, and recipes are for baking. Mine was a warm grey with a touch of raw umber in it, and I used it for the better part of a year without noticing that every canvas had the same weather in it.
Going back to one that fights you is the right instinct. Not because suffering makes good paintings but because a grey you have to argue with keeps you awake in front of the thing.
You are right, and it is the part I know already and still need to hear. A grey that behaves becomes a habit fast, and the habit is the death of the thing. I have a whole shelf of failures that were each, once, a good idea repeated until it meant nothing.
The raw umber and white, I know that one. Warm and safe and it flatters everything you put near it, which is exactly the trap. Mine got no name, but it got a proportion, and I could mix it with my eyes shut. That is the warning sign.
What I am doing now is letting it go wrong on purpose in the third layer. More solvent, less control, let the thing break a little. So far the grey holds and the surface is less obedient. We will see.