My contact sheet got more work than my finished pieces

Someone on here mentioned process shots not moving the needle. Opposite for me. A couple weeks back I posted a rough shot of the workbench, half-carved piece still in the stone, dust everywhere, chisels out. Not staged. Just where I left it at the end of the day. That one brought more commission inquiries than any finished piece I've put up this year.

Makes sense if I think about it. People don't buy a sculpture, they buy watching it get made. The finished thing is already decided. The messy middle leaves room for them to picture themselves in it.

Funny part is I almost didn't post it. Looked like a mess to me. My daughter posted it for me while I was still grinding. She's the one who runs the account, I'm just the labor.

Still feels backwards that the work no one was supposed to see does the best. But I'll take it over chasing trends.

4comments

Add your reply to this discussion…

4 comments

Sol Reyes·2h

This makes so much sense and I hate that it's true for me too lol. I don't do contact sheets but I've had the same thing happen, posted a half-finished charcoal of a figure, face not even there yet, just the gesture and the mess, and people went nuts over it. Way more than the finished ones.

I think you're right about the "already decided" thing. A finished piece is a statement, it's closed. But the messy middle is where someone can step in and feel like they're part of it somehow. Like they're getting to watch something happen instead of just looking at the result.

Also honestly? The finished thing is when I'm most insecure about it. All the doubt is still in the room but you can't see it anymore. The process shot shows the doubt and people connect to that more than the polish.

Anyway, not staged is the key. I think people can smell a fake process shot from a mile away. Yours worked because it was real.

Roman PetrakOP·2h

Charcoal's a good example of it. Nothing there to judge yet, so nobody judges. They just get caught up in the pull of it. A face finished tells them what to think. A gesture lets them fill the rest in themselves.

And yeah, the finished stuff gets the credit in the end, but it's the messy ones that bring people through the door. I've started posting the bench more and the polished work less. Seems backwards but the numbers don't lie.

Karen Wessel·2h

This is so interesting because I've noticed the exact same thing with my acrylics. I posted a photo of my palette mid-session once, paint scraped all over, a half-finished sky that looked terrible, and it got way more engagement than the final piece I put up the week before. I knew it didn't look good, I almost deleted it, but people just love the in-between stuff apparently.

I think you're right about the finished thing being "already decided." There's nothing to add to it. But a messy workbench or a half-carved stone, people get to fill in their own story about it. Maybe they imagine themselves as the kind of person who makes things.

Curious what it is about the workbench shot specifically that pulled so hard for you. Was it just the dust and chaos, or do you think there was something else in the frame that people latched onto?

Roman PetrakOP·1h

Same thing with the palette. I've seen painters do that and never thought twice about it. But you're right, it's the same principle. The paint sits there like the workbench does. Nothing decided yet.

That half-finished sky you almost deleted. That's the one that hit. The finished sky is just a sky. The messy one has all the possibility still in it. I don't think people want to fill in their own story, exactly. I think they want to catch it before the story gets written.