My torn paper edges all curl the same direction and I can't unsee it now
Someone in a crit last week said my collage work has "a consistent gesture" which I think was a polite way of saying every torn edge I make curls the same way. I checked three old pieces this morning. Yeah. Every single one, the paper rolls toward the same side. I tear with my right hand, pull down and left, every time, for years. It's like finding out you have a signature you never signed.
Not sure if this is a thing to fix or just lean into. It's not a bad look honestly, the curl catches light. But now that I've seen it I can't stop seeing it, and knowing it's muscle memory kind of grosses me out. Anyone else ever find a habit this dumb baked into years of work?
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
The fact that you can't unsee it is exactly why you should keep it. A mark you can't control is the closest thing to a real signature. Anybody can learn to tear paper a hundred ways, but you built one way into your hand without deciding to. That's not a mistake, that's material.
I think about this a lot with printmaking, actually. The plate wear, the registration being slightly off, the way the ink pools differently on the same edition. The things you'd call flaws if you didn't know better, but they're what make an edition feel alive instead of manufactured. You can't fake that consistency. You could spend six months trying to vary your tears and you'd still default back to the same gesture under pressure.
Curls catching light is not nothing either. That's an effect, not a defect. Maybe the question is less "should I fix it" and more what happens if you lean in so hard it becomes the whole point of the work. Make it so deliberate people think you planned it for years.
That's a good word right there. You're talking about the thing that makes a piece yours before you even know you made it. I sewed for years before I noticed I cut every corner a little different, every one leaning the same way. Same as you said, muscle memory I never signed. I used to try and fight it, straighten myself out. Then one day I looked at my grandmother's old quilt hanging on the wall and saw she did the same thing with her binding corners. She'd been gone twenty years and there she was, still in the stitch. That settled it for me.
That curl of yours is your hand saying your name on every piece. Let it talk.
your grandmother's binding thing got me. that's the whole argument right there. my mom's handwriting is identical to her brother's and she never noticed until we dug out old birthday cards. you don't see yourself in the work until someone else points at it. then it's all you can see.
i think i'm gonna keep the curl honestly. it's mine. if someone in another crit flags it again i'll just tell them i meant it.
the plate wear thing got me. i never thought about printmaking that way but you're right, the stuff you can't help is what reads as human. i keep wanting to fight it though, like my hand should do what i tell it and this is proof it doesn't. maybe the gross feeling is just that. finding out you're not as in control as you thought.
i showed a friend today and she said the curl makes the piece look like it's been handled a lot, like someone's actually lived with it. which is a nice spin i guess. i'm still on the fence but leaning toward keeping it. thanks for the printmaking bit, that'll stick with me.