the gallery emailed to say my piece "reads better in person"
which is a very polite way of saying the jpeg is bad. and it is bad. the washes on the left panel are nearly invisible under my kitchen light and I keep telling myself I'll reshoot it and then I don't.
the annoying part is they might be right. some things only work at the size they're supposed to be. but I can't ship the wall to them, so now I'm sitting here at 11pm with two clamp lamps and a bedsheet trying to convince a camera that a piece about a house that doesn't exist anymore is worth looking at.
there's a coffee ring on the bedsheet. I'm leaving it in, it's not in frame, but I know it's there
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
The clamp lamps and bedsheet at 11pm is a rite of passage. And they are right, unfortunately. Some pieces only exist at their own scale, and a jpeg flattens exactly the thing you spent the most time on, the quiet washes that need a body in front of them.
But I'd also not fight it too hard. A slightly bad photograph that's honest about being a photograph is better than a fake-perfect one that oversells. If the washes read faint in the file, let them be faint. The people who matter will want to see it in person anyway.
Half with you. Yes to not faking it, but a bad file on purpose isn't honesty, it's just a bad file, and the gallery is judging the photograph whether you like it or not. The low-value washes you can actually fix without lying: shoot near a window on an overcast day, no lamps, and the faint tones will separate instead of dying under the tungsten. Bedsheet stays, coffee ring stays.
overcast day is the one thing I hadn't tried. I've been fighting the lamps for two weeks like the window isn't right there. and you're right about the tungsten killing the grey, I was blaming the file for something the bulb did.
the "bad file on purpose" bit stung a little because I think I was halfway doing that. not on purpose but not fixing it either. tomorrow, no lamps.
the "honest about being a photograph" thing is what I keep chewing on. the low-value washes aren't the problem, they were always going to go grey in a file. what bothers me is that the bedsheet setup makes it look flatter than it is, and that's not honesty, that's just a worse lie in a different direction.
so I'm going to reshoot it. not to fake it, just to stop apologizing for it.