The gallery no that turned into a yes somewhere else
Y'all ever had a gallery say no but leave you with something you didn't expect? Mine was years back, a woman up in Chattanooga looked at my quilts, turned one over slow like she was reading it, and said "these aren't craft, they're testimony" and still didn't take me on. Sent me home with her card and a word about a fiber show I'd never heard of. That show got me my first real collector.
I think about her sometimes. She never did hang my work, but she gave me more than a wall ever would. Got a gallery "no" that turned into a door opening somewhere else? Or one that just made you pack up and keep going?
3
6commentsSaveFollow threadShare
the "these aren't craft, they're testimony" thing gets me. that's a person actually looking at the work even while passing on it. most no's are just form emails or a quick glance, but that kind of attention is rare and it stays with you.
i had a similar one, not a gallery. a curator in a group show jury told me my triptych was "too cluttered" and then spent ten minutes talking me through which pieces she thought held it together. i was furious at the time, thought she was being passive aggressive. took me like a year to realize she was right and she was trying to help. i still think the final version is her more than mine, honestly.
weird how a rejection that's honest does more than a wall full of yeses. glad that fiber show worked out for you.
The "too cluttered" one hits home. People think a harsh no is the bad outcome, but a lazy yes is worse. Nobody ever learned anything from "great work, maybe next time."
The curator who told you what she saw, even while saying no, that's a real eye on your work. That's rare. Most of them look at the wall around the painting, not the painting itself. I've had my share of both, and I'll take an honest read over a polite brush-off any day. The honest ones are the only ones that change how you work.
Took me a long time to learn the knot in your stomach when you hear the truth about your own painting is the fee you pay for getting better. You paid that one, sounds like it was worth it.
Now that's the truth, honey. A lazy yes just leaves you patting yourself on the back and not one step closer to anything real. But an honest no, one where somebody's actually looking at your work and telling you what they see, that'll sit with you and work on you for years.
Your point about the wall around the painting, that's sharp. So many of 'em are looking at the frame and the lighting and who else is in the show, not the piece hanging there asking to be seen. The ones who really look, even when they turn you down, they're the ones worth listening to.
And I'm glad you said the part about the knot in your stomach. That honest read stings at first, no getting around it. But it's the only kind that changes how you work. A polite brush-off lets you stay comfortable. That knot you're talking about, that's the thing that makes you go back to the studio and try again, different.
That curator could've just let you be mad and moved on, but she took the time to tell you what she saw. That's somebody who cared about the work even while she was passing on it. And Lord knows that's harder to accept in the moment. I remember being so hurt by that woman in Chattanooga I didn't hardly hear a word she said for a month. Then one night I was sitting at my machine and it come back to me, all of it, and I could finally see she wasn't turning me away, she was giving me a key.
I'm glad you finally got to take it. Did that triptych ever get reworked, or did it stay the way it was and you just understood it better? Sometimes knowing why somebody says no changes how you see your own piece too.