The subtle shift in what makes engagement real

I've noticed a trend lately, or maybe I'm just noticing it now. It feels like the harder we try to engineer 'engagement,' the more people tune out. I spent last week looking at some analytics for a project, trying to get a spike in likes or shares on a particular piece of content. We tweaked the hook, adjusted the CTA, even played with the posting time. Nothing moved the needle much. Then, coincidentally, I posted a photo of my messy studio floor, paint tubes everywhere, a half-finished canvas in the background, with a caption just saying 'Work in progress.' It got more genuine interaction – people asking about the paint, the process – than the polished piece we'd spent days on. It makes you wonder if the 'performance' is the problem, not the content itself. C'est ça, non?

4comments

Add your reply to this discussion…

4 comments

Margaret Hsu·4w

This resonates with me. I often find the most meaningful connections happen when the artifice drops away. In my own work, I'm always striving for accuracy and a certain technical precision, which can feel very deliberate. But when I share a glimpse of the process – a smudge of pigment on my hand, a slightly off-kilter brushstroke I've yet to correct – that's often when people seem to connect most authentically. It’s the imperfection, the vulnerability, that draws them in, not the polished final product. It’s a good reminder that authenticity, even in its messiest form, often speaks louder than carefully curated perfection.

Camille LaurentOP·4w

C'est ça. It's the trace of the hand, no? The final polish can feel sterile. People want to feel the effort, the struggle even. Your point about technical precision is interesting – it’s easy to mistake that for the whole story. A well-drawn line doesn't always have life, but a slightly hesitant one, if it's honest, can sing.

Dimitra Vasilakis·4w

This rings so true. I see it in the studio all the time. You spend hours setting up a shot, trying to make it look perfect for Instagram, and maybe a few people tap 'like'. Then you snap a quick photo of the dust on a finished piece, or a funny little accident with the grout, and suddenly people are asking questions, leaving comments. It’s like they can smell the real effort, the actual process, behind the polished thing. People connect with the human bits, the mess and the effort. It’s the same with mosaic, I suppose. The finished piece is one thing, but showing the chipped tiles, the uneven bits before they're grouted… that’s where the connection starts. It’s good you’re seeing this too.

Camille LaurentOP·4w

Exactly. It’s the ‘human bits’ that draw people in. That photo of my studio floor was almost embarrassing in its mess, but it felt more honest than anything else I’d posted that week. People want to see the reality, not just the curated highlight reel. The dust, the accidents, the little imperfections – that’s where the story is.