The weld that held after I told myself it wouldn't
Had a piece out in the weather since 2019, a tall steel form on a corporate plaza downtown. I welded it with a guy half my age helping me, and I argued with myself the whole way about one joint near the base. Wind load, thermal movement, all of it. I knew better. Did it anyway because the schedule said so.
Went by there today to check on something else and stood under it for a while. That joint is clean. No cracking, no rust bleeding through the seam where I was sure it would go. Thirteen years on steel and I still don't trust a good weld until the weather has had a few seasons at it.
Checked every connection while I was there. All of them fine. Thought about telling the young guy who helped me but I dont know if hes even still fabricating. Some people move on from this work.
Just nice to be wrong about a thing once in a while.
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
There's something almost philosophical about this. You make something, you argue with yourself about one decision in it, and then the weather becomes the only honest critic. All that doubt about that joint and it just... held. Like the thing knew better than you did.
I get the not-trusting it part though. With printmaking I'll pull an edition and know the plate is good but I still can't call it done until weeks later when I've seen the same print in different light, different rooms, hung next to things. The proof is time, not your own judgment. You can't be the one to certify your own work.
Thirteen years is a long time for a weld to keep proving you wrong, in the good way. I'd take that as the universe finally signing off on it.
The weather as the only honest critic, that's it exactly. I've made things I was sure about that failed in a month, and things I almost didn't put out that held for years. My judgment has no predictive power over my own work. Embarrassing to admit but true.
The print thing resonates too. Different rooms, different light, seeing it next to someone else's piece. That's when it either earns it or doesn't. You can't see your own stuff clearly until it's been somewhere you aren't.
You're not wrong about the judgment part, and it's not embarrassing, it's just the job. The work you doubt is usually the work you thought hardest about. The stuff you're sure of is the stuff you stopped questioning, and that's when you get sloppy.
The other rooms thing is real too. I used to think I could tell by walking around a piece early on. Can't. Takes distance, and time, and usually somebody else's bad lighting before you see what you actually made.
Printmaking is a good comparison. Paper and ink, you can't rush the verdict on it either. Different light changes everything, you're right about that.
The honest critic part sticks with me. I've had pieces fail that I was sure about within a year. That's the humbling part of this work. Your judgment gets better but it never gets infallible, so you learn to live with the doubt instead of fighting it. Doubt keeps you careful. It's the confidence that'll kill you.