Took a commission I knew I shouldn't. Now I'm grinding through it like penance.

Took on a piece last month I had a bad feeling about from the first call. Client kept saying "modern" and "organic" and I should've known those two words don't sit together in steel. Now I'm three weeks in and fighting the material to make something that's neither.

My own fault. I've got a rule about turning down work when the first conversation feels like a puzzle instead of a handshake and I broke it because the money was good.

The honest part: the fabrication is fine. It'll hold up. That was never in question. It's just dead on arrival and I know it, and the client will love it because they don't know any better, and that's the part that sits wrong. Charging someone for a thing you'd never stand behind if your name went on the plinth.

Anyway. Ten more days and it's out of the shop. Next time I remember why I made the rule.

6comments

Add your reply to this discussion…

6 comments

Lukas Brandt·4d

That rule you've got, about the puzzle versus the handshake, is a real one. I've broken it enough times to know the money never quite pays for the slow death of making something you don't believe in. The grinding is the worst part, worse than the bad result, because it takes three weeks out of the work that should have been yours.

The client loving it anyway is its own punishment, I know that too. It tells you the whole exercise was a transaction and nothing more, and somehow that makes it emptier than if they'd hated it.

The only thing I'd add: don't let it eat the next piece. Sometimes the penance is just finishing the thing and then forgetting it existed. The dead ones teach you more than the good ones ever do, if you let them.

Karen Wessel·4d

That second part is the thing I keep circling too. The client liking it anyway is almost worse. Like it was never really about what you made at all, just that you made it. I've done a few commissioned pieces where I just phoned in something competent and they were thrilled and I walked away feeling like I'd gotten away with something instead of actually proud of it.

I like what you said about not letting it eat the next piece. That's the hard part. I did a commission like this last fall and it took me a solid month after to even want to pick up a brush for my own stuff. Felt like I'd used up all my good intentions on something that didn't deserve them.

Hope the next one's a handshake for you. Those are the ones that keep you going.

Roman PetrakOP·4d

Yeah, that month-long dead zone after. I know it. You finish the thing, it ships, and the shop just sits there. Nothing feels worth starting because you're not sure your eye is still yours.

I think that's why I finally wrote it out here. Naming it takes some of the poison out. The last piece I genuinely loved, I didn't make for anyone. Maybe that's not a coincidence.

Did the brush eventually come back for you, or did you have to force the first one?

Roman PetrakOP·4d

You've got the transaction part right. That's what bothers me most at the end of the day. Not that it's bad work, it's not. It's competent. But there's nothing in it I'd claim. Just a shape that satisfied a brief.

And you're right about the next piece. I've already got a block of granite sitting in the yard that's been waiting since spring. Might be time to quit sulking and get to it.

Giulia Bruno·4d

The puzzle versus the handshake thing is a good way to put it. I think we all have a version of that rule and we all break it exactly once too many and then spend weeks in the studio feeling like we're doing time.

What gets me is that bit where the client will love it. There's something almost worse about that. If they hated it you could at least fight. But they'll hang it or install it or whatever and be genuinely happy and you'll walk past your own signature on it feeling slightly sick.

I did a screenprint commission like that a couple years ago. Big corporate lobby, they wanted "energy" and "movement" which in practice meant they wanted the same abstract wave pattern everyone's cousin has. I delivered it and they paid and I've never told anyone in my program about it. Not proud of that either. The money was very good though, which is the trap, obviously.

You'll finish it. You always do. But maybe hold onto how this feels for the next time the money talks, because the memory of this exact week is the only thing that's ever actually worked as a rule for me.

Roman PetrakOP·4d

The signature thing. Yeah. You hit it. Welders marks and mine are next to each other on the base and I keep thinking about grinding mine off before it ships. Not out of shame. Out of not wanting to be on the hook for something that never had a pulse.

But you did a screenprint for a corporate lobby. That's a different kind of fight. At least steel I can argue with. It pushes back or it doesn't. A screen is pretty much doing what it's told from the start, so if it comes out dead that's on you, nobody else. I don't know how you walked out of that one.

The "energy" thing is the giveaway too. Soon as they say that word you know there's no shape in their head, just a feeling they're renting from a magazine. My client said "organic" and I should've hung up right there.