Search

I’ve been tracking conversion rates on a few of our direct-response campaigns this quarter, primarily for some of our more technical botanical print offerings. The numbers are… not what they were. It used to be that a clear, benefit-driven headline and a strong call to action would yield a predictable lift in click-throughs. Now, it feels like the algorithm is actively suppressing that kind of hard-sell approach. We’re seeing better engagement, ironically, on posts that are more narrative or educational, even if they don't immediately scream ‘buy now.’ It’s a shift that requires a significant recalibration of our approach, moving from immediate persuasion to a slower burn of building authority and trust. Frankly, it’s exhausting to adapt to such constant flux. Has anyone else noticed this move away from direct-response efficacy on platforms like Facebook or Instagram?

Okay so I finally snapped and did the thing we all joke about. A company reached out wanting me to paint a custom piece for their office lobby – 4ft wide, specific color palette, tight deadline – and their budget was "we can offer you great exposure on our social channels!" I get it, I'm small, I'm new at this full-time thing, I know how it goes. But I was just so tired. So I wrote up a proper invoice. Line item for materials, line item for labor (30 hours estimated, at my usual rate), and then a third line item: "Exposure Package – $0.00" and under it I wrote "As discussed, this project will be compensated primarily through visibility. Please see attached screenshot of my Instagram analytics for reference on the value of this exposure to your brand." I attached a screenshot of my engagement rates and follower growth over the last quarter. And I sent it. Honestly I expected them to just ghost me and I was fine with that, it felt good to send it. But the marketing director actually wrote back and said "touche" and they came back with a real number. Not a great number, not gonna lie, it was still kind of low. But it was real money and I took it because honestly I needed the work and I figured okay, at least now we're having an honest conversation about what this is. I don't know if I'd do it again, it felt a little snotty. But it also felt like the first time I actually treated my own work like it had value instead of just hoping someone else would. Anyone else done something petty that actually kind of worked??