Why I keep the ugly blocks in the quilt
I was laying out a quilt top today and there was this one block, mustard yellow with a piece of plaid cut wrong that don't sit square with nothing next to it. My first thought was to pull it out, tuck it away where only I know it's hiding. Then I remembered my grandmother's rule. She never took a block out once it was sewed in. Said a quilt's like a congregation, ain't supposed to be all the same people. Somebody's got to be the one that keeps the rest honest.
I left it in there. That plaid block is going to be somebody's favorite part one day and I'll smile and not say a word about how it fought me the whole way. That's the thing about this work, you don't get to fix everything. You just keep going and let the crooked parts hold their own weight.
3
4commentsSaveFollow threadShare
That grandmother of yours knew something most people learn too late, if at all. I build rooms out of other people's cast-offs and the same rule applies. The one piece that doesn't fit is usually the one the whole thing turns on. The rest is just arrangement.
I also think there's a quiet kind of honesty in keeping the mistake where everyone can see it. Costs you nothing, teaches you everything. Beauty you have to work around is worth more than beauty that just shows up.
I like what you said about the piece that doesn't fit being the one the whole thing turns on. That's exactly it. When I'm pulling prints and one plate is off register, slightly crooked, that's the one that holds my eye longest. The perfect ones I walk past. There's something about the visible fault that makes you actually look instead of just admire.
And your last line, beauty you have to work around, that's the whole argument for the imperfect in a nutshell. We've convinced ourselves the finished thing should look like it fell out of a machine. But the work that means something usually shows the hand, or the struggle, somewhere.
Now you're speaking my language, honey. Off-register, crooked, that one plate that won't settle, and it's the one that keeps your eye coming back. I know exactly what you mean. The perfect ones, you glance at em and move on. But that little flaw, it sits there asking you to look again, like it's got something to say.
And what you said about the machine thing, that's the truth. We got so used to things coming out clean and even we forgot that handmade means somebody was there. That somebody leaves their mark whether they mean to or not. I used to worry over my crooked seams something awful. Then one day I looked at my grandmother's quilt on my bed and I counted seven seams that weren't square, and I couldn't tell you one of em without going and looking. But I can tell you every patch of her Sunday dress she worked in there.
That's what lasts. The looking. The remembering.
"Beauty you have to work around is worth more than beauty that just shows up." Now that's a line I'm going to carry with me all day. You build rooms out of cast-offs, so you know exactly what I'm talking about. There's a difference between making something and arranging it, and the arranging is where the life is.
I bet you've got stories in those walls, honey. A crooked doorframe somebody couldn't square up, and it turned out to be the thing that made the room feel like a place somebody actually lived in instead of a picture from a catalog. That's the same congregation my grandmother was talking about. Keep that off-register plate where it belongs. The rest of us see it plain as day and it blesses us. 🙏