Search

Had a collector ask me last month what a life-size figure in limestone would run. I've danced around it for years, always said "it depends," gave ranges so wide they meant nothing. This time I just told him. 14,000. He didn't blink. I think I could have said 18 and he still wouldn't have blinked. The math is the part nobody sees. A block that size, good French limestone, that's 2,000 plus freight to the studio. Then the roughing-out alone is two to three weeks. I'm not counting my shop rate on that, I'm counting what I'd be paid to do the same labor on someone else's piece. It comes out to about nine dollars an hour once you add the finishing and the patina and the weeks it sits while the stone settles. Nine dollars an hour for a skill it took me thirty years to build. And the guy was ready to pay more. I'm not sure what that says about me or about the market, but it sits wrong. I've been charging what I was afraid to charge, not what the work is worth. Still. Scared to raise it because the last big commission I quoted at 16, the client went somewhere else. Might have been the price. Might not have. But it's in my head now.

Two years on this one. It was a 400 lb Indiana limestone block, upright, meant to be a figure. I kept carving to the drawing and it kept looking like a boulder with a suggestion in it. Took it down to 180 lbs last month. Dumped the rest in the yard. I've been fighting that block since I got it. Drawings were fine. The problem was I was carving the block I ordered instead of the block that was there. The whole thing started reading different once the mass came off. I don't have a better way to say it than that, and I'm not going to pretend it was a decision I made on purpose. What finally pushed me was a mason I've known since the 90s walked through and said nothing for a while and then asked what the block weighed. I told him. He said well, that's your problem. He wasn't wrong. Delivering it to the client in two weeks if the weather holds.

Charged $4,800 for a six-foot limestone piece, installed. Took five weeks. Client paid without a word, which is how I knew I'd left money on the table. Roughing it out cost me two diamond blades and a $340 core bit that grabbed and snapped when I hit a hard pocket. Nobody sees that. The client sees a rock with a hole in it. They pay for the shape, not the pile of dead tooling in the corner of the shop. I price stone by the cubic foot plus labor, and I've never once put tool wear into the quote. Three decades and I still eat it. My old man did tile for forty years and priced by the square foot the same way, and he died with a garage full of worn-out blades and a house he never finished paying on. I'm raising the next quote by 15 percent. Not because I got braver. Because the math finally caught up with me.

Four hours to take 3/8 of an inch off a limestone base. That's not slow, that's about right, but try explaining it to anyone who doesn't do this. Point is you can't just whale on it. You score, you chase, you check it against a straightedge every few passes, and if you get impatient the stone spalls at the corner and now you're carving a new edge instead of leveling the one you had. I've seen guys ruin a week of work in ten minutes that way. I did it myself at 24. Still have the piece somewhere as a reminder. The client wanted it flush and I told them flush costs more than they think. They said fine. It'll be flush. Nobody's going to look at this base. That's the whole point of a good base.

Got a limestone reclining figure, about three feet, been on it for two months. Undercut the shoulder too deep last week. Meant a soft turn there, and instead there's a shadow line you could fit a finger into. Stepped back and for a day I thought I'd ruined it. Then I stopped looking at what I meant and looked at what was actually there. The piece shifted. Shoulder's gone, but now the head carries the whole weight and the body reads as something laid down differently than I planned. It's not what I drew. It might be better. Not sure yet. That's the whole job right there, knowing when a mistake is a mistake and when it's the piece telling you something. I've killed more work by forcing it back to the drawing than I ever lost by following it. But it's hard to trust, especially after that much time into one block. Anyone else got a piece that turned because you cut wrong and let it stay wrong?

Three months wrestling this block. Seven hundred pounds of limestone. Had it laid out on the shop floor all summer, working it from the top and sides because I couldn't tip it without a rig I didn't have. Finally borrowed a neighbor's gantry this weekend, got it upright and onto the base without cracking anything or losing a finger. It's not finished. But it's standing. That's a different thing than lying down. When you work flat you're making a drawing in stone. Standing up, it starts talking back to you. Whole different set of decisions now. Took a photo of it in the afternoon light through the shop door. First time it's looked like a real piece. Might post it later if I don't talk myself out of it.

Got talked into a portrait bust in Indiana limestone last fall. Widow wanted her husband, done from photographs. Quoted 6,000. Sounded like money. Here is what it actually was. Block was 1,400 delivered, and I bought two because the first had a hairline seam I didn't trust. 900 in abrasives and a new set of carbide points, which I needed anyway but they came out of this job. Six weeks of mornings on it, and portraits are the slowest work I do because a face is unforgiving, you can't fudge a nose. Then the pedestal, cutting and setting, another 400 in material and a day I didn't bill. Add it up and it's under 30 an hour. A stone mason down the road bills 85 for a stoop, no face on it, done in two days. The bust came out right, which is the only reason I'm not angry about it. But I've been quoting faces off the block cost alone for years and that's a mistake. Talked to a guy who does bronze and he prices the whole commission off the finished weight. I don't know if that holds for stone but I'm done pretending carving a face costs the same as carving a wall.

Block of Indiana limestone, about 300 pounds when I started. Client wanted a torso, waist up, no arms. Simple. I roughed it in with the saw and a point chisel and it sat in the shop three weeks while I did a rail job. Went back at it Monday and the shoulder line is wrong. Not crooked, wrong. I took the ridge too far back on the left side and now the whole thing reads like it's turning away from you when it should be squared up. I know exactly where I went wrong too. I was matching the drawing instead of the stone and the stone didn't have that much there. Two options. Take 3/4 of an inch off the right shoulder to match and lose the mass I wanted, or build up the left with a dutchman and hope the seam doesn't show when it's dry. I've done both before. The patch has held on pieces twenty years old, but you can always find it if you look, and this one's going to get raked light across it in the client's entry. What I keep coming back to is that the "wrong" version might be the better piece. Turning away is more interesting than squared up. But I didn't carve it on purpose and I don't know if I can trust that. Anyway. Cutting tomorrow either way. Stone's already paid for.

Finished a limestone piece in 2009, 300kg, sat on the client's porch in Vermont ever since. Four years ago I was up there for something else and saw a crack running out of the bottom left corner, about six inches, following the bed plane. Nobody else noticed. I've thought about that crack maybe twice a month since. Here's the part that bothers me. I knew that stone had a seam there when I blocked it out. I could feel it under the chisel, that slight give. And I set the piece so the seam sat in the least loaded corner and called it fine. It was fine. It's still fine. That's the problem. Nothing teaches me anything. I have a new block in the shop now, Indiana limestone, 180kg, and there's a seam in it in almost the same place. I've been walking past it for three weeks. I know the correct answer is to cut the block down and lose the mass, or send it back and eat the freight. What I actually want to do is set it the same way and tell myself I'm being practical. I've done that before. So this is me saying out loud that I'm not going to do it. I'll report back when I've ruined a smaller piece instead.

Every piece of limestone I carve ends up the same way. I pick the block, map out the form, rough it in right, and then about halfway through I start chasing the vein. There's always this one line of darker stone running through it and I keep trying to work with it, shape around it, make it mean something. It never works. The piece ends up looking like I fought the material instead of the material and me agreeing on something. I did it again this week on a 200 pound piece of Indiana limestone and I knew better the whole time. I told my old mentor about it once. He just looked at me and said the vein isn't the problem, you are. I've been chewing on that for fifteen years and I still don't know if he meant I should stop trying to feature it or stop pretending I can ignore it. Maybe it's the same thing. Anyone else got a habit that keeps repeating even though you know exactly what you're doing when you do it?

I'm not good at pricing what my time is worth and I know it. Married couple wanted a limestone piece for their garden. Simple shape, clean lines, nothing fussy. I quoted $6,000 thinking that was plenty. 80 hours later I'm doing the math. Block of limestone was $1,100. Delivery of the block was $300 because it had to come on a flatbed. The chisels I wore down and replaced, maybe $150. Then the base I fabricated to mount it, another $200 in steel. That's $1,750 in costs. Leaves me $4,250. Divided by 80 hours, that's $53 an hour before taxes. Not terrible for a sculptor maybe but I'm not a young man and my body feels those hours now. The thing is they were happy. They paid without blinking. So I left money on the table and they'd have given me more. That's on me. I don't know how to fix this. I've been doing this long enough I should know what I'm worth. But I still anchor low and feel guilty asking for more.

Pulled it out today to sweep up. There's a century of limestone dust caked into the folds, plus a wad of cured 5 minute epoxy from a commission I don't want to think about. My wife used to make me throw them out once a year. I don't anymore. There's something useful in a dirty floor. It tells you where you stand without lying. Every chisel mark, every dropped mallet head. A clean shop is a shop where nothing is getting made. I know some of you keep your benches photo-ready. I don't get it. Half the time I don't even sweep until the dust gets into my coffee cup. Anyway. Sanding a limestone base today, nothing else. Anyone else superstitious about their mess?

Spent the morning on a piece of Indiana limestone I've been working for two weeks. Block was clean, good color, no veins. I kept pushing on it. Refining a curve that didn't need refining. At noon I stepped back and saw what I'd done to it. Took that curve too far. Now I'm chasing it back. Thirty years in and I still do this. The stone tells you when you're done and I keep going anyway because stopping feels like I'm being lazy. Had a mentor who'd slap his hands on his thighs and walk away mid-afternoon. I thought he was slacking. He wasn't. He just knew. Now I spend half my time carving and the other half wishing I'd walked away an hour earlier. If you're at the point where you're just fiddling, put the tool down. The work is already done. Fiddling is how you ruin it.

Still sitting in the corner of the shop. A five-foot chunk of Indiana limestone I took on six years ago. Customer wanted a figure, paid half up front, then disappeared. I stopped waiting after year two but I can't bring myself to cut it up for scrap. Every few months I walk past it and think about what it wanted to be before I took the commission. I knew better. You never take on work you don't believe in just because the money's good. But I did, and now there's this block I walk around like a piece of furniture I hate. Anyone else got a piece like that? The one that should have been something else but you made the wrong deal and now it just sits there.

I'll go first. My first real show, I walked in with a portfolio of photos and the director barely looked at it. What got me the meeting was a maquette I carried in under my arm, ten pounds of limestone, actual work. He picked it up, put it down, and said "bring the big one." So what was it for you. The thing that actually opened the door. A body of work, one piece, a referral, a price that made them look twice. Doesn't have to be a happy story. What did you put on the table.

Took a commission for a carved limestone piece last winter. Eight weeks of work on and off. Quoted $4,800 and the client said "that's it?" which I should have read as a warning about myself, not a compliment. I broke it down after delivery. Stone cost $620. Studio overhead, sanding discs, carbide, the rented truck to haul the block, my time at what I actually worked, it came out to about $11 an hour. I've been doing this thirty years. I still price like I'm afraid someone's going to find out I'm not worth it. The client was happy to pay more. I was the one who couldn't ask. Raised my rate last month for the first time in four years. $65 an hour. Feels like robbery. That's the whole problem.

Picking out a block of limestone this morning. Twenty years I've been buying from the same yard. Kid working there, maybe 25, sees me checking for fissures and starts telling me about CNC waterjets and how much waste I could save. I told him I don't want to save waste. I want the stone to tell me where to cut. He looked at me like I was speaking Latin. Not mad about the tech. It's fine for some things. But I'm not trying to produce units. I'm trying to find what's already in there. You can't program a machine to do that and pretending you can is how you end up with a thousand identical smooth river stones that all look like nothing.

Been thinking about how long it takes me to learn a stone. People think you pick a material once and you know it. No. I've worked limestone for thirty years and it still surprises me. A block from one quarry will hold an edge like it's got something to prove. Another from twenty miles away, same color, same grain to the eye, and it'll spall off under your point chisel if you breathe on it wrong. You can't get that from a book or a video. You get it from ruining a few good pieces and remembering exactly how it felt when it went wrong. The sound it makes right before it lets go. That's the tuition. I watch young sculptors post these perfectly polished things and I wonder what they learned making them. I'm not saying polish is bad. I'm saying the learning is in the near misses, the ones you keep in the corner because they taught you something even though they'll never sell. Just finished a piece where I knew by the second hour what the stone wanted. First time in a long time. Took thirty years to get there. Still got the scar from the one that taught me that particular lesson.

Back when I was still doing fabrication for other artists, I used to buy a lot of limestone from this old guy out in Indiana. Third generation quarry family. Tough customer. You showed up late, he'd make you wait. You talked too much, he'd just walk away mid-sentence. One day I'm complaining about a commission that fell through. Client loved the maquette, then ghosted. I'd put three weeks into it. He's loading stone onto my truck and he doesn't even look up. Says "Did you ask for money before you started?" No. Of course not. I was young and wanted the work. He says "Then you didn't have a client. You had a hope." That stuck with me. For years I operated like making the thing was the hard part and selling it would just happen if the work was good enough. That's not how it works. The stone dealer knew that. The gallerists I've dealt with know it too, they just don't say it out loud because the silence benefits them. I'm not saying be a salesman. I'm saying the transaction is part of the arrangement, not an afterthought. If you can't talk about money with someone before you make them anything, you don't have a deal yet.

Woman wants a garden piece in limestone. I measured, I told her 3 feet tall, 900 pounds, delivered and set on a proper base. Gave her a number. She says she loves it. Forty minutes later she calls back. Can we do four feet. Same price. Forty inches of extra stone doesn't come out of the air. Bigger block, bigger crane, bigger base, and I have to hand it anyway. I told her no. She acted like I'd insulted her. The part that gets me is she thinks size is a preference. Like picking a color. It isn't. Every inch changes what the stone can hold up. Go past a certain point and the ankle of the piece gets thin and it fails in ten years, and I'm the one whose name is on it. Block is already sitting in the yard. I'll cut it down to three feet and it'll stand for a hundred years. That's the whole offer.